Crafting the Evening Elixir: Mimicking Coffee's Comfort Without the Caffeine

Question: When I’m trying to enjoy a coffee-like experience in the evening without any caffeine, what’s a clever way to replicate the rich aroma and warmth using readily available ingredients?

The allure of coffee extends beyond its stimulating effects, encompassing a rich tapestry of aromas and a comforting warmth that many seek to replicate, especially in the evening when caffeine is undesirable. Fortunately, readily available ingredients can be combined to evoke a similar sensory experience.

The Foundation of Flavor: Roasted Roots and Pods

The characteristic deep, roasted aroma of coffee is largely attributed to complex volatile compounds developed during the roasting process. While coffee beans themselves contain these compounds, other roasted ingredients can provide a similar olfactory and gustatory foundation. Roasted chicory root, a traditional coffee substitute, is renowned for its earthy, slightly bitter, and roasted notes [13]. Similarly, roasted carob powder, derived from the pod of the carob tree, offers a naturally sweet, chocolatey, and roasted profile that can complement the earthiness of chicory [4]. These ingredients, when brewed, release a spectrum of volatile compounds, including those that contribute to the sensory depth associated with coffee.

Unlocking Aromatic Complexity with Spices

To further enhance the coffee-like experience, incorporating specific spices can add layers of complexity and warmth. The aroma of coffee is a sophisticated blend of hundreds of volatile compounds, with sulfur-containing compounds, like 2-furfurylthiol, playing a significant role in its characteristic roasted and nutty notes [8]. While replicating this exact profile without coffee is challenging, certain spices can introduce complementary aromas. For instance, the warm, slightly sweet, and woody notes of cinnamon can evoke a sense of cozy indulgence. Nutmeg or a pinch of cardamom can introduce subtle spicy and aromatic nuances, reminiscent of some coffee flavor profiles, such as those found in coffee pulp wines which can have notes of spice and fruit [4]. These spices, when gently heated or infused, release their own volatile compounds, contributing to a richer aromatic bouquet.

Brewing for Warmth and Aroma

The preparation method is crucial in maximizing the aroma and warmth of these caffeine-free alternatives. Similar to brewing coffee, steeping these ingredients in hot water allows for the extraction of their soluble flavor compounds and the release of volatile aromatics. A ratio of roughly two tablespoons of a mixture of roasted chicory and carob (proportion can be adjusted to taste) per cup of hot water can serve as a starting point. Allowing this mixture to steep for 5-10 minutes, much like a prolonged coffee infusion, can help to deepen the flavors and aromas. The heat of the water itself contributes to the comforting warmth, while the steam carries the released volatile compounds directly to the olfactory senses [12, 13].

To achieve a richer mouthfeel and further mimic the body of coffee, a touch of unsweetened plant-based milk, such as almond or oat milk, can be added. This not only softens the flavors but also adds to the overall warmth and creamy texture, enhancing the indulgent aspect of the beverage. The combination of roasted ingredients and warming spices, prepared through a hot infusion process, effectively replicates the rich aroma and comforting warmth associated with enjoying a cup of coffee, providing a satisfying decaffeinated alternative for any time of day.

References

[1] — Magdalena Zdanowicz, Marta Rokosa, Magdalena Pieczykolan, Adrian Krzysztof Antosik, Katarzyna Skórczewska — Biocomposites Based on Wheat Flour with Urea-Based Eutectic Plasticizer and Spent Coffee Grounds: Preparation, Physicochemical Characterization, and Study of Their Influence on Plant Growth. — 2024-Mar-06 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38473683/ [2] — Gustavo Galarza, Jorge G Figueroa — Volatile Compound Characterization of Coffee ( — 2022-Mar-21 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35335365/ [3] — Katarína Poláková, Alica Bobková, Alžbeta Demianová, Marek Bobko, Judita Lidiková, Lukáš Jurčaga, Ľubomír Belej, Andrea Mesárošová, Melina Korčok, Tomáš Tóth — Quality Attributes and Sensory Acceptance of Different Botanical Coffee Co-Products. — 2023-Jul-11 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37509767/ [4] — Rongsuo Hu, Fei Xu, Liyan Zhao, Wenjiang Dong, Xingyuan Xiao, Xiao Chen — Comparative Evaluation of Flavor and Sensory Quality of Coffee Pulp Wines. — 2024-Jun-27 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38999011/ [5] — Faguang Hu, Haohao Yu, Xingfei Fu, Zhongxian Li, Wenjiang Dong, Guiping Li, Yanan Li, Yaqi Li, Bingqing Qu, Xiaofei Bi — Characterization of volatile compounds and microbial diversity of Arabica coffee in honey processing method based on different mucilage retention treatments. — 2025-Jan — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39974542/ [6] — Yang Q, Yuan Y, Lyu D, Zhuang R, Xue D, Niu C, Ma L, Zhang L — The role of coffee and potential mediators in subclinical atherosclerosis: insights from Mendelian randomization study. — N/A — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39119461/ [7] — Megan Fuller, Niny Z Rao — The Effect of Time, Roasting Temperature, and Grind Size on Caffeine and Chlorogenic Acid Concentrations in Cold Brew Coffee. — 2017-Dec-21 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29269877/ [8] — Guihu Zhang, Peng Xiao, Mengmeng Yuan, Youming Li, Youqiang Xu, Hehe Li, Jinyuan Sun, Baoguo Sun — Roles of sulfur-containing compounds in fermented beverages with 2-furfurylthiol as a case example. — 2023 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37457986/ [9] — Osman Cagin Buldukoglu, Serkan Ocal, Serdar Akca, Galip Egemen Atar, Ferda Akbay Harmandar, Ayhan Hilmi Cekin — Relationship of coffee consumption with colonic diverticulosis. — 2025-Aug-01 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40751228/ [10] — Ernesto Illy, Luciano Navarini — Neglected Food Bubbles: The Espresso Coffee Foam. — 2011-Sep — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21892345/ [11] — Valeria Hurtado Cortés, Andrés Felipe Bahamón Monje, Jaime Daniel Bustos Vanegas, Nelson Gutiérrez Guzmán — Challenges in coffee fermentation technologies: bibliometric analysis and critical review. — 2024-Dec — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39431196/ [12] — Esteban Narváez, Esteban Zapata, Juan David Dereix, Carlos Lopez, Sandra Torijano-Gutiérrez, Julián Zapata — A Comparative Analysis of Cold Brew Coffee Aroma Using the Gas Chromatography-Olfactometry-Mass Spectrometry Technique: Headspace-Solid-Phase Extraction and Headspace Solid-Phase Microextraction Methods for the Extraction of Sensory-Active Compounds. — 2024-Aug-10 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39202870/ [13] — Panagiota Zakidou, Fotini Plati, Anthia Matsakidou, Evdoxia-Maria Varka, Georgios Blekas, Adamantini Paraskevopoulou — Single Origin Coffee Aroma: From Optimized Flavor Protocols and Coffee Customization to Instrumental Volatile Characterization and Chemometrics. — 2021-Jul-29 — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34361765/